Trying to choose between Mauritius, Zanzibar, and Thailand can feel like the ultimate travel dilemma.

Each destination brings sunshine, beaches, culture, great food, and the kind of holiday glow we all love. 

But depending on your travel style – foodie, adventure lover, culture enthusiast, romantic traveller, or family planner – one destination may suit you better than the others. 

This blog breaks down the three top tropical vacation destinations and answers the big questions travellers often ask. 

4 Key Takeouts Before You Start Reading 

1. Mauritius is the smoothest, easiest, and most luxurious choice, especially for couples and families. 
2. Zanzibar stands out for culture, spice, charm, and excellent value for money. 
3. Thailand offers the most variety – food, beaches, nightlife, adventure, and cultural depth. 
4. Budget-wise, Zanzibar and Thailand usually cost less – and we’ll always match you to the best holiday package to suit your budget and needs at Thompsons. 

Let’s Compare Mauritius, Zanzibar and Thailand Category by Category 

Food: What can you expect? 

Mauritius 
Mauritius offers an impressive mix of Creole, Indian, French, and Chinese influences. Resorts often form a major part of the dining experience, with buffets, themed restaurants, and generous menus included in many Mauritius packages. 

Zanzibar 
Zanzibar’s food is rooted in history – spice-rich dishes, coconut-based curries, grilled seafood, and local treats like Zanzibari pizza. Dining feels warm, aromatic, and aligned with the island’s cultural heritage. Enjoy all-inclusive Zanzibar packages with Thompsons Holidays. 

Thailand 
Thailand is a food-lover’s paradise. Pad Thai, green curry, fresh seafood, night markets, and street food stalls make eating an experience in itself. Many travellers choose Thailand packages solely for the cuisine. 

Beaches and Sights: What will you see? 

Mauritius 
Mauritius is known for its calm, sandy beaches and sheltered lagoons. You’ll also find beautiful natural attractions like Chamarel’s Seven Coloured Earth, waterfalls, and lively markets in Port Louis. 

Zanzibar 
Zanzibar has some of the whitest beaches in the Indian Ocean. Stone Town adds a fascinating layer of history, with spice farms, Jozani Forest, and scenic snorkelling spots offering plenty to explore. 

Thailand 
Thailand delivers variety: dramatic cliffs, turquoise bays, golden temples, island-hopping days, and colourful markets. There’s always something new around the corner. 

Which is more beautiful, Mauritius or Zanzibar? 

Mauritius has polished beauty. 
Zanzibar has natural, untouched beauty. 
The “better” choice depends on the style you prefer. 

Adventure Level: How active do you want to be? 

Mauritius 
Activities include zip-lining, catamaran cruises, stand-up paddling, kitesurfing, snorkelling, and scenic walks. Everything is well-organised and easy to arrange through resorts. 

Zanzibar 
Zanzibar offers laid-back adventure: snorkelling at Mnemba Atoll, swimming with turtles, spice tours, dhow sailing, and wandering through Stone Town’s old streets. 

Thailand 
Thailand takes the lead for adventure. Rock climbing in Railay, hiking to temple viewpoints, island hopping, kayaking, zip-lining in Chiang Mai, and exploring national parks – perfect for travellers comparing Thailand or Zanzibar or Mauritius or Thailand. 

Kid-Friendliness: How easy is it for families? 

Mauritius 
The top family choice. Most resorts have exceptional kids’ clubs, calm lagoon waters, family rooms, and dedicated activities. Mauritius is widely considered the easiest island holiday for families. 

Zanzibar 
Family-friendly if you choose the right resort. Many offer kids’ clubs and shallow beaches, though the overall experience is simpler and more rustic than Mauritius. 

Thailand 
Thai hospitality is incredibly warm toward families. Resorts are well-equipped, but travelling between islands or cities requires slightly more planning. 

Romance: Best for couples? 

Mauritius 
Think luxury suites, private beach dinners, sunset cruises, and indulgent spa experiences. Mauritius is one of the top honeymoon choices and a clear winner for effortless romance. 

Zanzibar 
Zanzibar has a naturally romantic feel – boutique beach lodges, sunset views, rooftop restaurants, and peaceful beaches. It’s intimate and culturally rich. 

Thailand 
Thailand offers a wide range of romantic options, from private pool villas in Koh Samui to quiet beachfront stays in Khao Lak and luxury resorts in Phuket. Ideal for couples who want a mix of relaxation and adventure. 

Which island is better for a romantic getaway? 
Mauritius for luxury. 
Zanzibar for charm and character. 
Thailand for romance combined with variety. 

Culture: How immersive is the experience? 

Mauritius 
A gentle blend of Indian, French, Creole, and Chinese influences. Expect colourful temples, friendly locals, and casual cultural encounters. 

Zanzibar 
Zanzibar has an incredibly strong cultural identity – Swahili traditions, Arab architecture, spice heritage, music, and storytelling. Stone Town is a highlight for culturally curious travellers. 

Thailand 
Temples, festivals, markets, street performances, and everyday local life make Thailand the richest cultural experience of the three. 

Value for Money: How far does your budget go? 

Mauritius 
Generally pricier, especially at luxury resorts. The quality is excellent, and the experience is seamless – but it does come at a higher cost. However, Thompsons will match you to the right Mauritius package that suits your budget and needs, so you can enjoy the island without the stress of overspending. 

Zanzibar 
Often much more affordable, especially for South African travellers. Many travellers are surprised at the value of Zanzibar packages. 

Is Zanzibar expensive for South Africans? 
It can be extremely good value – and we will match you to the best holiday package to suit your budget and needs at Thompsons. 

Thailand 
Thailand consistently delivers excellent value. Food, transport, and activities tend to cost less, making it popular for longer stays. 

Which island holiday is the cheapest? 
Usually Zanzibar or Thailand – depending on your travel dates and resort choice. 

Choosing Your Perfect Island Escape 

Each of these island holiday destinations offers something different: 

If you’re still unsure, chat with us at Thompsons. We’re experts in Mauritius packages, Zanzibar packages, and Thailand packages, and we’ll help you select the destination, resort, and holiday package that best match your travel style and budget. 

Your next island holiday is waiting – let’s plan it together.